Cat owners are often at their wit’s end when finding a litter their feline friend will use. It can even be a bigger challenge if your cat is picky about its litter.
If your cat sticks its paw in the litter and scoffs in disgust before walking away, this may be the time to try a new litter. As you would want a litter box that attracts your cat, you’ll want to find a litter with the scent and texture that your cat prefers.
Getting a cat litter that your finicky feline will love may take some trial and error, but it will be worth it when you finally find one that your cat likes. Your cat will no longer prefer your couch or carpet to the litter box. And it will be a win-win situation for you and your cat.
While there’s no surefire way to please every cat, there are some cat litters on the market that are more likely to win over a finicky feline.
Here are seven of the best litters for picky cats:
7 Best Cat Litters for Picky Cats Reviewed
1. Fresh Step Odor Shield Scented Litter with the Power of Febreze
Fresh Step Odor Shield Scented Litter with the Power of Febreze is a clumping litter created with your feline friends’ health and happiness in mind.
This litter promises to control odor and leave your home smelling fresh. Not only does it have the power of Febreze, but it is also scoopable so that you don’t have to deal with any stinky crumbles.
Fresh Step cat litter is also low in dust, meaning it won’t get all over your house, and your cat will be less likely to track it around. It is also scented, so your cat will appreciate the fresh smell.
One of the great things about this litter is that it is formulated for the stinkiest litter boxes. It has activated charcoal that helps to get rid of any bad smells. If your kitty likes to go number two in their litter box, then this is the perfect litter for you.
- Forms tight clumps
- Controls odor
- Low dust
- It has activated charcoal
- Maybe too fragrant for some cats
- Not flushable
2. ökocat Natural Wood Cat Litter
ökocat Natural Wood Cat Litter is made from clean wood fiber. The wood fiber is screened and dusted to create an absorbent and lightweight litter. The litter is further enhanced with natural wood enzymes for exceptional odor control.
This cat litter is plant-based and made from renewable resources. It is also 99% dust-free, which means it is healthier for you and your cat.
The ökocat litter clumps well and is easy to scoop. It is also compostable and biodegradable. ökocat Natural Wood Cat Litter is an excellent choice for cat owners looking for a natural litter that controls odor well. It does not have any added scent or chemicals.
- Natural ingredients
- Odor control is exceptional
- Clumping well
- Compostable and biodegradable
- Maybe a little more expensive than some other litters
3. Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Premium Clumping Cat Litter
Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Premium Clumping Cat Litter is an excellent option for the pickiest cats. It is made of 100% natural clay and forms hard clumps. It is also 99.9% dust free and ideal for sifting and mechanical litter boxes for easier disposal of your cat’s litter.
Suffer from allergies? Fret not! Dr. Elsey’s cat litter is hypoallergenic and perfect for cats and people with allergies. It is ideal for multi-cat homes and comes in a large 40-pound bag. It also has superior odor control, ensuring your home stays smelling fresh and clean all day long.
The medium grain clay makes it perfect for dumping litter that will not stick to your cat’s paws. It is also easy to scoop and dispose of. Overall, this is an excellent litter for picky cats as it will not stick on their paws or cause allergies. It also has superior odor control capabilities.
- 100% natural clay
- Forms hard clumps
- Superior odor control
- Ideal for multi-cat homes
- It cannot be flushed
4. Naturally Fresh Walnut-Based Quick-Clumping Cat Litter
Naturally Fresh Walnut-Based Quick-Clumping Cat Litter is a natural cat litter made of walnut shells. It is a scoop-able litter and forms tight, strong clumps. The quick clumping action prevents the formation of long-lasting odors.
The all-natural ingredients make it an excellent choice for people with allergies or cats with sensitive skin. It is also dust-free and does not stick to the paws of your cat, ensuring there is no tracking.
The walnut shells are super absorbent and can hold up to three times their weight in moisture. Its super absorbent feature makes it more durable than other natural litter. Being eco-friendly and 100% biodegradable makes it a great choice for conscientious cat owners looking for environmentally friendly litter.
- 100% environmentally friendly
- Tight, strong clumps
- Natural ingredients
- No tracking
- It does not mask the bad odor
5. Purina Tidy Cats Low Dust Clumping Cat Litter
Are you in the market for low dust, natural clay cat litter? Purina Tidy Cats Low Dust Clumping Cat Litter is your ideal choice. It is made with natural clay, mineral products, and a deodorizing system perfect for multiple cat households.
It is designed to trap odor and form tight clumps for easy scooping. This litter is ideal for a household with many cats as it helps control odors in between cleanings. The feathery weight design makes it easy to pour and carry. The litter is also 99% dust-free, making it healthier for you and your cat.
The activated charcoal helps to eliminate bad odors, while the ammonia blocker prevents new smells from forming. This litter is a great choice for people looking for a low dust, clumping litter that controls odor well.
- Low dust
- Odor control
- It is not flushable
6. Boxiecat Premium Clumping Cat Litter
Boxiecat Premium Clumping Cat Litter is one of the best cat litter for picky cats. It is vet recommended by Dr. Lisa Frank and is two times longer lasting than other litters.
The exceptional odor control for ammonia will keep your home smelling great. It forms rock-hard clumps that form on the top for easy scooping.
The low tracking granules will not stick to your cat’s paws and will be easy to clean up. It is also ideal for allergic people and cats. Your cat will love the soft, fluffy texture of this Cat Litter.
Boxiecat Premium Clumping Cat Litter is ideal for a senior cat or a cat with medical conditions that cause urinary incontinence. It is also great for households with multiple cats. This litter comes in various sizes and colors to match your home decor.
- Vet recommended
- Odor control
- Clumps on the top for easy scooping
- Low tracking granules
- It comes in various sizes and colors
- It cannot be flushed in a toilet
7. BoxiePro Air Lightweight, Deep Clean, Scent Free, Hard Clumping Cat Litter
Got a long-haired feline friend? BoxiePro Air Lightweight, Deep Clean, Scent Free, Hard Clumping Cat Litter is your perfect bet. This cat litter forms tight and non-stick clumps that can’t stick to your cat’s fur.
It is 60% lighter than clay-based litter as it’s made with non-clay ingredients that are plant-based. It has a natural fresh plant aroma that will keep your home smelling great.
The lightweight clumping makes it easy to scoop, and the airtight clumps prevent the spread of waste in homes. It eliminates odor caused by bacteria and is 99.9% dust-free.
This litter was awarded the 2019 pet business industry recognition award. BoxiePro Air Lightweight, Deep Clean, Scent Free, Hard Clumping Cat Litter is a great choice for cat lovers looking for an environmentally friendly litter that’s dust-free and controls odor well.
- Lightweight clumping
- Airtight clumps
- Natural fresh plant aroma
- Quite expensive
What to Consider When Buying Cat Litters for Picky Cats
When buying cat litters for picky cats, there are a few things you should keep in mind. Some of the factors you may want to consider include:
The Type of Litter
There are various types of cat litters available on the market so that you can find one that fits your cat’s preferences and your needs. Some of the most popular types of litter include clumping clay, crystal, silica gel, and natural/biodegradable litter.
Clumping clay is suitable for cats that like to dig and are easy to scoop, while natural/biodegradable litter is a good choice for eco-conscious cat owners and those with allergies.
The Dust Level
If you have a cat prone to allergies or respiratory problems, you will want to choose a litter with a low dust level. Most litters these days are relatively low in dust, but it is still something you should keep in mind when making your purchase.
Some litters are unscented, while others have a light, fresh scent. If your cat is sensitive to smells, you will choose an unscented litter.
The Size of The Particles
If your kitty has long fur, you will want to choose a litter with small particles that will not stick to its fur. Litters with large or medium-sized particles are ideal for long-haired cats.
Medium-sized particles will also be trackless and easier to scoop. They will not stick on the paws of your cat while walking.
There is a variety of high-quality litter available at various price points, so you should find one that perfectly fits your needs. While you don’t want to choose a litter based purely on its price, you should consider how much you want to spend on cat litter.
The Optimal Choice
The best cat litter will narrow down to the type of texture, scent, and price you are willing to spend. It will also be based on the amount of tracking, dust, and odor control you desire.
Even though not all litters are created equal, one litter that rises above the rest is Fresh Step Odor Shield Cat Litter. This litter excels in all of the areas important to picky cats – it is unscented, has a low dust level, and the particles are small enough that they will not stick to your cat’s fur. It is also affordable and comes in a large bag that will last you for some time.
Our second choice is ökocat Natural Wood Cat Litter. This litter is made from 100% renewable and sustainable materials and is free of chemicals, fragrances, and clays. It has excellent odor control properties and is low-tracking. The only limitation is that it is more expensive than some of the other litters on the market.
However, you should answer some questions that you will ask yourself before purchasing your optimal choice of cat litters for your picky cat:
- How often will you need to scoop the litter?
- How much money are you willing to spend on cat litter?
- What type of litter does your cat prefer?
- What are your cat’s allergies or sensitivities?
The list given above for the best cat litter for your picky cat can give you a good idea about the litter you should buy for your cat. You should also consider the factors to make a better decision. All the products listed here have pros and cons, so it is ultimately up to make a decision on what one will be great for your needs and your cat’s preferences.